paperKB
coga / coga-kb
Processing
Help
Sign in

Chunk #44 — I. Heritability of Aggression: Twin and Adoption Studies — F. Criticisms of twin and adoption studies: Assumptions and generalizability

Source
Human aggression across the lifespan: genetic propensities and environmental moderators.
Embedded
yes

Text

boys and r = 0.35 in families of girls) and concluded that assortative mating is modest in degree. Another study using data from the Dunedin sample in New Zealand (Silva and Stanton, 1996) when the participants were 21-years-old found a correlation (r = 0.54) between couple members' reports of antisocial behavior in their peers (i.e., participants were asked how many of their friends had aggression, personal, alcohol, or drug problems, or did things against the law), which was identical to the correlation for couple members' reports of their own antisocial behavior as measured by a variety of offenses (e.g., theft, force, fraud, vice). They concluded that assortative mating for antisocial behavior is substantial and that antisocial individuals tend to cluster in peer groups with similar antisocial peers. As such, assortative mating should to be taken into account when modeling antisocial behavior (Krueger et al., 1998). It is interesting, however, that the shared environmental effects are fairly negligible in twin studies of aggressive behavior, both in the prior meta-analyses as well as in our summary in Table 8.2. Thus, any assortative mating for aggression does not appear to have resulted in severe overestimates of shared environment when considering these studies en